Guides · For diners
Service charge vs. tip: what diners and servers should know
More bills now include a line like “service charge 20%” or “gratuity included for parties of 6 or more.” It looks like a tip, but it works differently.
The difference
- A tip is voluntary. You decide whether to leave it and how much, and it belongs to the staff.
- A service charge (including an automatic gratuity) is set by the restaurant. Legally it is revenue of the business. The restaurant may pass some or all of it to staff, usually as wages through payroll, but it does not have to in every state.
The IRS treats a charge as a tip only if the customer pays it freely, sets the amount, and decides who gets it. A mandatory charge fails that test, so it is taxed as wages.
Should you tip on top?
If the bill already includes a gratuity, an extra tip is not expected. If you are unsure where a “service” or “kitchen” fee goes, it is fair to ask your server. Many will tell you plainly whether staff get it.
For servers
Keep your service-charge share separate from cash and card tips in your records. It shows up in your wages, it is not reported as tips, and it does not count toward the federal deduction for qualified tips. It still counts as money you earned for that shift, so include it in your real hourly pay.